Skip to main content

$5 and a Few Bottles of Beer

In 1961 a man was accused of stealing $5 and beer from a pool hall. Unable to afford an attorney, Clarence Earl Gideon was forced to represent himself. He was convicted and sentenced to 5 years in prison. He filed a habeas petition with the Florida Supreme Court attacking the conviction on the grounds that the court should have appointed him counsel. Florida, of course, denied the petition.

Gideon filed suit against Louie L Wainwright, the Secretary of the Florida Department of Corrections asserting that he had been denied his Sixth Amendment right to counsel (as applied to the states via the Fourteenth Amendment). The Supreme Court granted certiorari. The rest is history.

Thousands were released from prisons in Florida as a result of the 1963 Gideon decision. Earl got another trial. This time he had the benefit of appointed counsel and he was acquitted.

Gideon v. Wainwright spawned the creation of public defender systems countrywide. These systems represent our country's attempt to protect the most vulnerable and marginalized amongst us: the poor and accused.

Let's be honest. We're trained to be drawn to wealth and popularity. Want to be left alone? Go broke. Want people to treat you like kryptonite? Be broke and be accused of a crime.

If you haven't figured it out, I am a public defender.
I do what I do because I love the Constitution. I love what the right to counsel can do. Yeah, I am an idealist, but there's a reality to my work as well. I think my brothers and sisters in the trenches would agree with me. Our clients are not heroically tragic characters you meet in a John Grisham novel. They are often not appreciative of the work you do. We are often insulted, disrespected, and discounted; sometimes the people who do it wear black robes. Despite all of that, we get up everyday and defend something greater than ourselves.

This blog is lovingly dedicated to the defenders of the indigent accused. We fight hard. We laugh hard. What we do is hard, but we wouldn't have it any other way.

NEXT: "How Can You Defend Those People?"

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Pretender

I'm not just a lawyer.  I'm a criminal defense lawyer.  To make matters worse, I'm a public defender.  Sometimes our clients call us pretenders, dump trucks, fake lawyers (as opposed to real lawyers or street lawyers). After 14 years in this line of work, I've learned to stop being offended.  I've learned to see the big picture and appreciate the privilege of it all.   Ever since I was a little girl, I wanted to be somebody's hero.  I often imagined myself standing in front of a vulnerable person holding a shield aloft to protect them from some overwhelming force.  Before I lost interest in Barbie dolls and Menudo, I knew that I wanted to spend my life defending people's rights.  That's what I prayed for.  That's what I worked for.  That's what I sacrificed for. As I child I was never great with making specific requests to God, and I guess that's how I ended up with my mixed bag of blessings.  Let's be clear.  How m...

Fountain Pens and False Accusations

I speak to my parents every single day.  Usually, I call at the end of my day to get an update on the lifestyles of the retired and rich ( richer than when they were raising a family). Today's conversation turned to what we can't escape, that event in Charlottesville that has thrown a mirror on America's racist sinister side. My father, now 71, offers a unique perspective on the a forgotten world.  His eyes first opened in the old South in Central Florida. He rode on the back of the bus, went to separate schools, and heard about people being lynched. He tells stories to us with ease, ranging from ones involving flaming bags of dog poop to that one time someone tried to shoot at him as he rode his bike as a child. He said, "Baby, when I see those white supremacists marching around with the full support of Donald Trump...when I see the Speaker of the House proclaiming that they hold the White House, the Senate, the House of Representatives, and the Supreme Court....